Comparison of audio codecs

del.icio.us del.icio.us
Digg Digg
Furl Furl
Reddit Reddit
Rojo Rojo
Add to OnlyWire

The following tables compare general and technical information for a variety of audio codecs. For listening tests comparing the perceived audio quality of audio codecs, see the article Codec listening test.

Contents

General information

General Audio Codec Information - creator/company, license/price etc.
Codec Creator First public release date Latest stable version Encoder Cost (USD) Player Cost (USD) Common implementations Application Patented DRM
AAC ISO/IEC MPEG Audio Committee 1997 ISO/IEC 14496-3 varies varies Proprietary: iTunes, Nero Digital Audio Open: FAAC and FAAD2 music Yes FairPlay
AC3 Dolby Laboratories 1992  ? varies varies Proprietary: DVD players, Digital television Open: FFmpeg movies Yes  ?
ALAC Apple Computer 2004-04-28 QuickTime 7.3 Free Free Proprietary: QuickTime, iTunes, Real Player Lossless Ripping for music  ?  ?
ATRAC Sony Corp. 1991 ATRAC3plus varies varies MiniDisc, Walkman, VAIO, Clie, PlayStation3, PlayStation Portable, SDDS, Proprietary: SonicStage, SoundForge, RealPlayer, ConnectPlayer voice recording, music, movies, Lossless Ripping mode for music Yes Yes
FLAC Xiph.Org Foundation 2001-07-20 1.2.1 Free Free OSI: reference Lossless Ripping for voice, music, movies, data samples No No
Monkey's Audio Matthew T. Ashland 2000+ 4.01b2 Free Free Proprietary Lossless Ripping for music  ? No
WavPack Conifer Software 1998 4.31 Free Free OSI: reference Lossless Ripping for music No  ?
Shorten Tony Robinson 1. Free Free Free Lossless Ripping for music No No
MP3 ISO/IEC MPEG Audio Committee 1993 ISO/IEC 11172-3 (See notes) (See notes) OSI: LAME; Proprietary: FhG music Yes
(but see notes)
No
Speex Xiph.Org Foundation 2003-03-24 1.1.12 Free Free OSI: reference voice recording No  ?
Vorbis (Ogg) Xiph.Org Foundation 2002-07-20 1.2 Free Free OSI: reference, aoTuV music No No
Windows Media Audio Microsoft Corp. 1999 11.0 Free [1] Free for licensees of the Windows operating system [4] Windows Media Player music Yes Optional
Musepack Frank Klemm/MDT 1997 1.16 Free Free OSI: reference music Maybe [5]  ?
Codec Creator First public release date Latest stable version Encoder Cost (USD) Player Cost (USD) Common implementations Application Patented DRM

Notes

  1. First public release date is first of either specification publishing or source releasing, or in the case of closed-specification, closed-source codecs, is the date of first binary releasing. Many developing codecs have pre-releases consisting of pre-1.0 versions and perhaps 1.0 release candidates (RCs), although 1.0 may not necessarily be the release version.
  2. Latest stable version is that of specification or reference tools.
  3. If there happens to be OSI licensed software available for a particular codec, this does not necessarily permit one to use said codec free of charge. Likewise, if there is only proprietary licensed software available for a particular codec, one might be able to use the codec free of charge.
  4. MP3 licence and patent status: The MP3 format is patented and therefore subject to license (expires latest: 2017 but US patents after Dec 2012 may be invalid). However with multiple contenders for the patent, it is far from certain in the market who is the patent holder with the right to set pricing and royalties. A sample of prices for one patent-holder is available. In practice, there is a wide range of MP3 authoring software and MP3 encoding worldwide is often performed on a private basis and unpaid, with patent rights unenforced against end users. See MP3#Licensing and patent issues.

Operating System Support

Audio Codec OS Support
Codec Windows Mac OS X Linux BSD Unix Palm OS
AAC Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
ALAC[2] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
FLAC Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Monkey's Audio Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
MP3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Musepack Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
RealAudio[3] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Speex Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Vorbis Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
WavPack Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
WMA[3] Yes Yes[4] Partial Partial Partial Yes

Technical details

Audio Codec Technical Details
Codec Algorithm Sample Rate Bit rate[5] Bits per sample CBR VBR Stereo Mono Multichannel
AAC Lossy, Hybrid 8 kHz to 192 kHz[6] 8 to 529 kbit/s (stereo) Any (typically uses fp internally) Yes Yes Yes: Dual, Mid/Side, Intensity, Parametric Yes Yes: Up to 48 channels
AC3 Lossy 32, 44.1, 48 kHz 32 to 640 kbit/s  ? Yes No Yes Yes Yes: Up to 6 channels
ALAC Lossless 44.1, 48 kHz variable 16, 24[7] No Yes Yes Yes Yes
FLAC Lossless 1 Hz to 1.04857 MHz variable 4, 8, 16, 24, (32) No Yes Yes Yes Yes: Up to 8 channels
Monkey's Audio Lossless 8, 11.025, 12, 16, 22.05, 24, 32, 44.1, 48 kHz variable  ? No Yes Yes Yes No
MP3 Lossy 8, 11.025, 12, 16, 22.05, 24, 32, 44.1, 48 kHz 8, 16, 24, 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 160, 192, 224, 256, 320 kbit/s Any (typically uses fp internally) Yes Yes Yes: Dual, Mid/Side, Intensity Yes No
Musepack Lossy 32, 37.8, 44.1, 48 kHz 3 to 1300 kbit/s 8 to 32 No Yes Yes Yes No[8]
RealAudio Lossless, Lossy Varies (see article) Varies (see article) Varies (see article) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes: Up to 6 channels
Speex Speech 8, 16, 32 (, 48) kHz NB: 2.15 to 24.6 kbit/s WB: 4 to 44.2 kbit/s  ? Yes Yes Yes: Intensity Yes  ?
Vorbis (Ogg) Lossy 1 Hz to 200 kHz variable Any (typically uses fp internally) Yes/ABR Yes Yes: Dual, Lossless, Phase, Point (Intensity) Yes Yes: Up to 255 channels
WavPack Lossless, Lossy, Hybrid 1 Hz to 16.777216 MHz variable in lossless mode; 196 kbit/s and up in lossy mode (for CD audio) varies in lossless mode; 2.2 minimum in lossy mode Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes: Up to 16 channels
Windows Media Audio Lossless, Lossy 8, 11.025, 16, 22.05, 32, 44.1, 48, 88.2, 96 kHz 4 to 768kbit/s, variable in lossless encoding 16, 24 for lossless mode, any in lossy mode (typically uses fp internally) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes: Up to 8 channels (WMA Professional), Up to 6 channels (WMA Lossless)

Notes & references

  1. ^ Windows Media Encoder
  2. ^ An open-source decoder for ALAC has been reverse engineered.
  3. ^ a b The ffmpeg project has reverse engineered some codecs of the RealAudio and Windows Media Audio (DivX Audio v1 and DivX Audio v2) formats. This enables their use on any POSIX compatible system.
  4. ^ Microsoft has outsourced their WMA support on Mac OS X to Telestream, Inc. who created and maintain Windows Media Components for QuickTime, replacing Windows Media Player for Mac OS.
  5. ^ Lossless compression is always VBR. [1]
  6. ^ MPEG 2 AAC was limited to a 96 kHz sampling rate, however, with MPEG 4 AAC, a later version part of the MPEG 4 specification, the maximum sampling rate has been increased to 192 kHz.
  7. ^ Apple Lossles Information [2]
  8. ^ Musepack SV8 beta with multichannel support [3]

See also

External links

This article is from Wikipedia. All text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License.


Giant Panda

Mercedes Car
James Bond Guide
This site monitored by SitePinger.net